Dessert for the Memorial Day barbecue is a must. And while we’d never say anything is better than our grandmother’s chocolate chip cookies, this year we’re going to see if the Crumbl cookie chain can give Granny a run for her money.

We snagged a four-pack from the new Crumbl location in Monroeville — another location opened earlier this year in North Huntingdon. Crumbl boasts an ever-changing lineup of cookies, so we got the standard sugar cookie with vanilla icing, coconut caramel with chocolate drizzle, Kentucky butter cake and chocolate peanut-butter chip.

How do they stack up? Find out:

What would you like to see the TribLive Taste Test squad try? Email pvarine@triblive.com and let us know!

Copyright ©2025— Trib Total Media, LLC (TribLIVE.com)