Editorial: Mixed mask messages for covid-19
Share this post:
When the chips are down, you listen to the people who know what they are talking about.
The firefighters say this is the way out of the fire? Go that way. The police say get down during a bank robbery? Lie on the floor.
So what do you do when different experts are dueling over the best course of action?
Right now, the smartest voices on stopping infections are divided on whether people should use masks when they go out in public during the coronavirus pandemic.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has been saying masks are not only unnecessary for the public but counterproductive. What the agency does recommend is that anyone who is sick — particularly with covid-19 exposure or symptoms — wear them around others.
The Washington Post is reporting the CDC is reconsidering that recommendation, claiming that while it will still push that surgical and N95 masks be saved for medical personnel, maybe simple cloth masks wouldn’t be such a bad idea for everyday use by regular people.
But at the same time, U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams has other thoughts. In multiple television appearances Tuesday, he rejected that advice, saying the research doesn’t support claims that masks help.
OK, then what are people supposed to do? This isn’t even a case of party-line divide where the GOP says one thing while liberals say another. This is different offices of the federal government taking different positions.
Some of it seems to be driven by the shortage of those medical-grade masks, and that has to be a factor. The people who need the masks most are the ones who are standing right in front of sick people, breathing the same air as they test and treat people before they move on to the next patient. They are not only at great personal risk, but if not protected, they could be a conduit to pass the disease along.
But others fear relying on masks could threaten the social distancing that does seem to be slowing down the exponential increase of positive cases.
“There is a possibility that constructing homemade masks, or even to wear masks in public as a healthy person, can provide a false sense of security,” said Dr. Gavin Harris, a UPMC infectious disease physician and critical care fellow.
In Pennsylvania, U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey has picked a side. He posted a video on Twitter calling on people to wear homemade face masks, tagging his message to join the existing #Masks4All movement.
The science may be out on whether masks help the general public. But as long as people continue to follow the rules for keeping distance and wash their hands generously, one has to wonder what they can hurt.